Tensions mar peaceful Greenville protest

Black Lives Matter protesters were met by counterprotesters during a march on Route 32 in Greenville on Saturday. Nora Mishanec/Columbia-Greene Media

GREENVILLE — The Greene County Sheriff’s Office is investigating an incident at Saturday’s Black Lives Matter rally in which a motorcyclist allegedly made contact with a protester.

The pedestrian was one of more than 150 people who descended on the George V. Vanderbilt Town Park to show support for the Black Lives Matter movement.

The protest did not result in any damage or injuries, Greene County Sheriff Peter Kusminsky said Monday.

Kusminsky confirmed that his office is looking into the incident involving the motorcyclist and the 27-year-old protester, who filed a report with the Sheriff’s Office following the incident.

Protesters walked the mile-long loop from Vanderbilt Park to Veterans Park and back, bringing attention to what several people called “a culture of close-mindedness” in Greenville that fosters hostility toward people of color.

But not everyone who came out Saturday appreciated the marchers’ message.

The Black Lives Matter supporters were met at Veterans Park by fierce opposition, including about 25 counterprotesters and a separate group of about 20 veterans who said they were there to protect the park from vandalism.

In addition to the incident under investigation by the Sheriff’s Office, one other counterprotester used his motorcycle to confront the marchers as they approached the park.

The motorcyclist drove in front of organizer Azraelle Story as she passed the Greenville Library, an incident that Story caught on camera. The driver was ticketed by police for operating his motorcycle on the sidewalk, Story said.

Some of the counterprotesters shouted obscenities at the crowd and several crossed the street to confront the Black Lives Matter protesters.

Story said she was taken aback by the vulgarity of the counterprotesters, but encouraged the Black Lives Matter marchers to remain respectful. She marshaled the crowd away from Veterans Park as tensions escalated, she said.

“I would not have brought my children if I had known that was how it was going to go,” Story said Monday.

Many participants, including Story, expressed their surprise at the high turnout. The march was intended to bring the town’s Black Lives Matter supporters out of the shadows, she said.

“I never realized how many people are like-minded,” she said. “I have never felt more connected to my community than I did [Saturday].”

Many marchers expressed similar sentiments.

“We need to show support for anti-racism in our rural community,” said Jaime Winans-Solis, who marched with her husband Jake Solis and their three children, who she said are among the “handful” of Latino students attending Greenville schools.

“People often say, ‘Racism doesn’t exist here,’ but just because people don’t see it doesn’t mean it’s not here,” Winans-Solis said.

The couple felt it was important to make their children aware of the Black Lives Matter and anti-racism movements.

“This is my first protest, but it won’t be their last,” Solis added, pushing a stroller as his toddler walked alongside him.

The group of counterprotesters, most without masks, stood on the opposite side of the road holding flags and signs with messages in support of the police.

Lynda Costello, of Freehold, said she rejects discourse that pits protesters against police.

Opponents of the Black Lives Matter movement often perpetuate a “false choice” between Black Lives Matter and the police, Costello said.

“It is specifically intended to divide,” she said.

In the days leading up to Saturday’s march, opponents of the march posted threats on social media and circulated rumors that protesters would be brought in on buses from out of town.

The “bused in” protesters never materialized Saturday.

The attendees came from the local community, said Chris Karle, a 10th-grade teacher at Greenville High School who brought along his kids, age 11 and 14.

Karle said he was “impressed and overjoyed” by residents’ support for the march.

“Everyone I saw was a local,” Karle said, adding that many of his students and former students attended, some with their parents in tow.

Several of the people who attended in opposition to the march said they did so out of fear that the protesters would become destructive.

A group of veterans, organized by Don Savino, of South Westerlo, stood guard in front of the gazebo at Veterans Park during the march.

The veterans were there to protect the park and show support for “the men in blue,” said Savino.

“We are protecting hallowed ground,” he said.

Ray Kosorek, of Westerlo, said he attended to protect the veterans monument and the flag from damage. Black Lives Matter protests have not had a good reputation, Kosorek said, adding he wanted to be sure the park’s veteran’s monument would not be defaced.

Such fears were unfounded, protesters said.

Story emphasized the peaceful nature of the protest.

“We wanted to bring no harm to the town,” she said. “We wanted to leave the town better than we found it.”

Story organized Saturday’s protest after unexpectedly witnessing the Hudson-Catskill Juneteenth Freedom March that took place on the Rip Van Winkle Bridge on June 20.

Story and her family watched from their car as a torrent of people marched past holding signs and chanting in support of the Black Lives Matter movement.

The experience galvanized Story to organize her own protest in solidarity with the Juneteenth marchers. But the organization process was not always easy.

Story said she faced hostility and intimidation on social media while publicizing the protest, which prompted her to alert state police and the Greene County Sheriff’s Office to the threatening nature of the online discourse.

Story advertised the event on a Facebook page for Greenville parents, but her post was removed by the page’s administrators.

Undaunted, Story moved forward with the planned march.

“I am so proud of my community,” she said following the march. “I want it to keep going. I don’t want it to stop here.”

Johnson Newspapers 7.1

(5) comments


The main problem is that these demonstrations were needed in the first place. The fact that is that Catskill and Greene County are deeply systemically racist. The jail is a primary example of misspent priorities. The Village of Catskill police budget is another, fully 50% of the $4 million budget. The web site shows an officer count of 21! Meanwhile the Catskill Community Center is being sold because there’s not enough financial support.

Now, add the atrocious mistake of tearing down 80 Bridge Street and you get a trifecta.

This has to change.

1st Amendment Supporter

What is "systemic racism?" The County Jail would be the proper place for a BLM molotov cocktail thrower, like Catskill resident Samantha Shader. Do you want to catch and release those charged with serious crimes?

1st Amendment Supporter

Nora Mishanec is a hack writer for a leftist rag newsaper, the Register-Star.

1st Amendment Supporter

Black Lives Matter? It's more like Black LIES Matter. These "protesters" could consider moving to the darker neighborhoods of Albany, Schenectady, Poughkeepsie, etc., where black on black violence, murders and mayhem occur about every weekend. Could those neighborhoods use more diversity? When you and your family feel unsafe in your new home, who ya gonna call?

Rory Van Deusen

BLM= Blue Lives Matter!!! Trump 2020! Jail is being built right NOW.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.